Drawing on their nontraditional paths to leadership, two higher education CIOs discuss building trust, navigating bias, leading change, and balancing human-centered leadership with difficult decisions. Along the way, they share candid advice for aspiring technology leaders and reflect on how AI may shape the future of higher education.
Takeaways from this episode:
- Successful CIOs are institutional leaders first, building relationships, trust, and a deep understanding of the business so they can align technology decisions with institutional priorities rather than simply deploy new tools.
- Leadership growth rarely follows a straight path, and career advancement often comes from saying yes to new opportunities, gaining cross-functional experience, and developing skills in change management, negotiation, and organizational strategy.
- Human-centered leadership and decisive leadership are not opposites; the most effective CIOs combine empathy and trust with clear priorities, difficult decisions, and a disciplined focus on the issues that matter most.
View Transcript
Cynthia Golden: Hi everybody. I'm Cynthia Golden and together with my co-host, Michael Cato, I'd like to welcome you to the Integrative CIO Podcast. During this year's shows, you may have noticed that there was kind of a theme running through some of them. We touched on things that relate to IT careers in a lot of our sessions. So it was everything from finding talent to leading in the age of AI, succession planning, building the pipeline for new leaders, and even navigating transitions. So today we decided to continue that theme and welcome a few CIOs to the show who will share some of their perspectives as women working in what continues to be a male dominated field. And from limited survey data I've seen, and some of you may have more precise data, but the CIOs, the number of women CIOs in our industry in higher ed has really hovered around the 20, 22% for a long time.
Cynthia Golden:So as we talk about career paths today, I'm hoping that we can spend a few minutes talking about our guest experiences as female CIOs as well. So let's meet our guests today.
Michael Cato: And today we are excited to welcome Penny Evans-Plants, CIO at Berry College. Hi Penny.
Penny Evans-Plants:Hi, thank you for having me.
Michael Cato: Happy to. And join me in welcoming Beth Clark, CIO at UC Irvine. Welcome Beth.
Beth Clark: Good morning. It's really good to see you.
Michael Cato: We are really grateful to you both for being here. So we though we'd start by asking each of you to say a few words about your career path, where you are now and where you worked previously. And Penny, if it's okay, let's start with you.
Penny Evans-Plants:Great. Thank you, Michael. So I'm a bit of an anomaly, I guess, in that I've worked my entire career at Berry, but I started out in the alumni office, believe it or not, and worked my way up over several years to become alumni director. And while becoming CIO certainly was not anywhere on my radar at all, I really enjoyed solving problems and understanding how technology could really help Barry do that. So it was back in the day of the '90s, and so we had green screens. We were on a system 36 and I taught myself enough RPG to be dangerous. I'm sure that our technology folks back then were cringing as I was able to modify my own reports. And then all that to say, to shorten that up, I moved into IT in 2000 and I'm saving the rest of that story for a little later in the conversation.
Michael Cato: Look forward to hearing it, Penny. And Beth, what about you?
Beth Clark: Yeah, so I recently joined the University of California at Irvine as their vice provost of IT and CIO. I did that in July after a 13-year tenure at the Harvard Business School. And I was at Boston College before that where I really started their academic technology practice and unit. But I didn't start in IT previous to that. I actually was in advocacy and policy work and found myself an accidental happy tourist in IT. But we'll unpack that as we go over the podcast.
Michael Cato: Really appreciate that, Beth. Well, I'm looking forward to our conversations even more so with these introductions. And maybe we could start by asking, and Beth, we'll start with you this time, was there a moment in your career that you think captures how you got to where you are today? You both have already in your intro said that this was let's call it a non-traditional path or an unexpected journey. How's that? Was there a moment in your career that helped that you look back on and realize it contributed to you being where you are now?
Beth Clark: Yeah, thank you for that question, Michael. I'd go back to my time at Boston College when I started. It was the 90s and it was really early days of the internet and very early days for academic technology. There was no practice when I joined Boston College. And so I was a department of one trying to establish something and establish a relationship with the faculty. And I think it was there when I fell in love with academia and the academic mission, which I think really did and has underpinned my journey in IT and just getting a good sense of the business, trying to understand what their needs were, helping them to really think about technology and pedagogy together and how to weave those two together. And I think that fundamental, I think, exercise of working closely with faculty of really understanding what they were trying to do their journey and the business of faculty, the teaching and learning and the research they were doing and the kinds of technologies that they were exploring, I think again was foundational for my work in IT.
Beth Clark: And I think that's been the common theme across all of my roles has been creating connection with academic side of the universe, which is really why we all have jobs in academia and really connecting the dots across their journey and how the administrative, I think, pieces all come together to make their work what it is and how they serve the institution and serve students as well.
Michael Cato: I really appreciate that, Beth. What about you, Penny? Was there a moment in your career that you reflect on that captures how you got where you are?
Penny Evans-Plants: Yeah, in fact, I'd say there were really two such moments. The first was when I really knew that I needed to make a change out of that alumni director role. We've had our first child and all the travel involved in alumni director was not very conducive to that. And so I had talked to my boss in advancement about what other opportunities might exist, and he really encouraged me to move into the director of development operations role, I think that's what we called it back then, to lead our conversion to a new ERP SIS. So at that time, Advancement had our own database, which we really wanted to merge during this process with the registrar's database to make one system for the institution. So as I mentioned earlier, of course, all this was happening in 1998, 1999, really leading up to Y2K. So then the second opportunity was really when that conversion was over and I had an opportunity to move into IT.
Penny Evans-Plants: So I had to take a demotion to do that, but I knew that that's where I needed to be after going through that process and discovered that... I know everyone's like, "You went through a conversion and you decided you loved IT. What is wrong with you?" But the data, and I had learned how to write SQL and I was like, "Oh my gosh, the logic, I just love this so much." But really the data interested me a lot even back then and knew that that was the direction that I really wanted to move into.
Michael Cato: Oh, that's beautiful. Actually, the part I was laughing about initially was that your boss's response to, "My life is changing, I've got new stresses, I can't be on the road," was take on ERP projects, it'll be so much better. That was my original laughter, so thanks.
Penny Evans-Plants: Well, his first suggestion was that I become a major gift officer, and I was like, "No, I don't want to ask for money and I sure don't want to travel doing that."
Michael Cato: Thank you both very much. Cynthia, I'll turn to you.
Cynthia Golden: Thanks. So as we talk about your career path, you've both just talked about some experiences that shaped your path in terms of moving into IT. Is there anything particular, any roles or any experiences that shaped your path toward a CIO, or was there a time when you began to see yourself as a senior technology leader? Penny, should we start with you?
Penny Evans-Plants: Sure. So I think me, what was so important was working in other areas of the college. And then when I moved into IT, I was in enterprise systems, which allowed me to work with all the different administrative areas at the institution. And this really helped me see how important it was to understand the business side, the data, and that strategy around our systems and our business processes and how all of that together can help us achieve our institutional goals. And as far as when I really began to see myself as a technology leader, I really go back to all the way back to 2005, and I don't know how all the things came together, but I won two different awards that year from Barry for my leadership. And I think that was a very pivotal moment for me when I'm like, "Oh, other people see this in me." And so later that year, I started my master's program in information systems because by that point I really knew I wanted to stay in IT as my career.
Cynthia Golden: Beth.
Beth Clark: Yeah, I think there were a couple of pieces that really resonated for me during my career. I'll start back when I was at Boston College and I needed to build a practice, and I really loved the process of developing a vision and then building a strategy and a plan and executing on it, taking something from nothing to something that was very meaningful for the institution. And that process was really fun for me. And then when I went to the Harvard Business School, I though I'd be going to Harvard, they'd have everything together. And the IT organization did not match the maturation of the institution and that there was a lot of change work to be done and a lot of building, I think, teams and processes and helping the organization again see where it needed to go and what those possibilities look like, and then really helping with the process of getting there.
Beth Clark: And so I don't know that I thought about it seeing myself as a technology leader, but I saw myself as an organizational leader with a kind of combination of skills that were helpful when it came to organizational development. And that was the ability to create a vision and create a strategy and roadmap, but also really understanding strategy execution and operations and tying those two together. So I wasn't just the idea person, I was able to take that idea and help execute on it, help the organization and execute on it. And I think doing that time over time, and I really love that process of organizational growth and development, I saw myself more as an organizational leader, and it did help me to expand my purview piece after piece of the organization at HBS until it was just like, "Oh, duh, here you go. Here's the whole organization.
Beth Clark: Just take it, please."
Michael Cato: Awesome. And it's interesting, one of the things I get curious about, especially because of the paths you both had, is there an example you could give of something that was harder than you expected as you started to advance into these senior roles? And maybe it looked like you've got an answer, Beth, so go for it.
Beth Clark: No, I was like, "Oh, I love this question. Everything is harder than it looks from." I think the process that you really have to go to to help manage expectations, I like to joke often that when you work in IT, it's equal opportunity for disappointment. You disappoint everyone, but you try to leave them with a smile on their faces. And so I think the process of really building the relationships so that you can have those difficult conversations when you can't move in a direction that a stakeholder wants to move in or you shouldn't move in that direction, I think the amount of negotiation that you do on a day-to-day basis I think was probably the most surprising. Nobody's surprised at problem solving in IT. We all love to solve problems, but negotiation and really building skills as a good negotiator and relationship builder I think were things that...
Beth Clark: The negotiation people, the negotiation piece I think was harder for me because I really like to make people happy. And so learning to do that in a way where there's a bit of happiness even when there's disappointment was skill that I needed to build over time, I would say.
Michael Cato: I really appreciate that, Beth. What about you, Penny? Is there something that surprised you that's been harder than you expected?
Penny Evans-Plants: Well, I don't know that my answer's a lot different from this, but the short answer I guess would be the people. Good ideas and good technology aren't enough. So higher ed is so relational and change requires trust, lots of trust, which takes time to build. And then the timing related to the change, patience, really understanding our culture. To Beth's point, building those relationships within the community, which then helps you build the trust, are also important and so hard to do and take so much work. You can't just come in and you don't have trust day one with someone, and it takes a lot of time and effort to build that kind of relationship.
Michael Cato: I really appreciate that. It's interesting because this is making me think about one of the challenges I've observed that, Beth, I think you said it, that technologists are problem solvers by nature or nurture, you get encouraged into this role, but that you realize over time that you need to negotiate to make sure you're solving the right problem or the problem the institution actually needs you to be focusing on. And if you don't do that work first, you can very easily end up solving the wrong one and creating even more challenges later on. Does that make sense? Does that resonate with you both?
Beth Clark: Yeah, 100%.
Penny Evans-Plants: In fact, I plan to talk about that very topic later in our conversation, but yes, it resonates very well because I think so many times people come to IT with the solution or the technology or the system that they want to buy without ever wanting to talk about what the problem is and identifying that problem and solving for the problem itself. And so we've really worked hard at that here to try to encourage our community to start with the problem first.
Cynthia Golden: Well, I think one of the themes that has run through a lot of our interviews that we've done, and I think Michael can attest to this, is the idea of relationships and the importance of building relationships and how much our work is based on that too. So I see this as we have these discussions all across our community. And in thinking about that, I think about how none of this, we don't do any of this completely on our own. And so as you've moved up the ladder and moved into CIO positions, was there someone or something, some experience that really helped you navigate challenges along the way? I don't know. Beth, you want to start?
Beth Clark: So many people have helped navigate challenges along the way. I mean, in some ways, this was a really difficult question to answer because you don't get anywhere in life without the relationships that you build and the support network that you build around yourself. But I was thinking about the pandemic and I was deputy CIO at Harvard Business School at that point in time, and I was working with Ron Chandler, who was the CIO at the time. And it was a difficult situation for the school, but he really, I think one of the things that he did so well that I took away during a very difficult time was his ability to just trust me implicitly and let me run with the work that needed to be done. And that made it so much easier because we had so much to do and he easily could have wanted to take over, but he didn't.
Beth Clark: He was so gracious and just handed things to me and said, "Please go do this. I really need you to do this and I need you to just do your thing." And I think the trust he put in me, and for me as a leader, I really think about that when working with others is making sure that I'm trusting them and the skills that they bring to the table so that I'm not getting in their way when they're trying to do something difficult. I'm supporting them in ways that empower them and they feel like they have the authority and the autonomy and the agency to do their best work. And so we all go through difficult times in IT all the time. Yesterday was no fun with Microsoft and having all day, but how do you free people to do their best work? How do you really support them to do their best work I think has helped me in, I think the toughest times I've had to do my best work.
Beth Clark: And just shout out to Ron because he's been such a great colleague and friend over the years, but really just I take away a lot of lessons from that time. And I just think about it often. It was a very difficult time for all of us.
Cynthia Golden: Yes, it was. And I know I have, in my career, I have appreciated it tremendously when people have placed their trust in me and let me do my thing. I think that's important. Penny, what about you?
Penny Evans-Plants: Yeah, I mean, like everyone, we've had some very challenging, difficult times at Barry through the years. As Beth mentioned, COVID was one of those periods of times and some others. But like Beth, I go back to the relationships that we formed and have built over the years. And I think about those groups of people. So whether it's the cheerleaders, the truth tellers, the mentors that I've had over the years to really support me and both on campus and externally. So I really was fortunate to be able to build up a network of folks through EDUCAUSE to really be able to talk to who were my mentors or colleagues that I could go to, to bounce things off of. And that was really helpful, especially during COVID, really seeing what other institutions were doing, especially smaller institutions more like Barry, having that network through EDUCAUSE has been really invaluable to me.
Cynthia Golden: I think that's one of the best things about our community about EDUCAUSE is giving us the opportunity to create those networks. I mean, whether you can afford to go to the conferences or not, you still have the infrastructure to be able to reach out to people from similar kinds of institutions and you're going to get a positive response and a helpful response.
Penny Evans-Plants: Yeah, agreed. I've been very fortunate to be one of the co-leaders now for several years at the small college CG group for EDUCAUSE and have gotten to know so many different people as a result of that. And it's just been so valuable and an opportunity to give back as well, particularly to women who are trying to find their way or find their path within IT.
Michael Cato: I really appreciate all of that. And Penny, you're leading us into the next thing we wanted to give some space to. As you might imagine, one of the reasons we were excited to have this conversation is that we often either sometimes a question or an answer to a question on the podcast or as people are giving us suggestions, there's a real desire to have conversations about the experience of our women leaders, especially in senior position. So I'm going to ask it more broadly, and maybe I'll start with you, Beth. Have you encountered assumptions or barriers related to being a woman in technology leadership? And if so, would you be willing to talk about maybe some examples and how did you respond?
Beth Clark: Sure. Yes, of course. Yes, of course there have been assumptions. There are assumptions. We as humans make assumptions based on just perceptions that we build up over time and stereotypes of what we think someone in a particular role should look like. And I'm five foot four and 98 pounds and my voice doesn't carry very far. And I started life as a social worker. And so of course people make assumptions about who I might be as a technology leader, and I just understand that. And I think it's been an interesting journey walking into a new institution just a few months ago and running into those same assumptions, even an institution that brings you in, really wants you there, and then you run into those assumptions of what could she possibly know?
Beth Clark: What could she possibly know? Oh, and she's a human-centered leader, so does she understand technology too? But I think for me, I'm very patient. I understand how we humans work and operate. And I think some of my early days working in human behavior and understanding how to unpack some of the assumptions and implicit bias that we all bring to the table helps me be very patient with people. And I don't really have, I don't know, I'm not a very defensive person. So for me, it's just having the conversation and helping to share the experience that I have. And I think once people get past those assumptions, they understand that I also have been in technology for 25 years and I have a lot of technical experience to bring to bear and a lot of things to share there. But generally, I bring patience and humor to the situation.
Beth Clark: If I find myself confronted with things, then I find that that smooths the path and generally gets us past some of those early, maybe first thoughts of who I might be as a technology leader. I think the other thing that I would mention though is that I think my style is a very warm style with IT organizations, and I think that is appreciated because I think the thing that I found that you can bring to the table is this care for the organization. And when people feel cared for, some of those other pieces melt away pretty easily. And I do try to really invest and care for the organizations that I'm coming into because they're made up of people who all need support and to feel supported and they need to feel supported by their leaders. And I think some of what you find early on goes away when people start to trust you and feel that you care for them and feel that you care for their best interest in carrying out the work that they do.
Beth Clark: It just happens.
Michael Cato: Really appreciate that. I apologize. I wasn't trying to interrupt you. Thank you so much for that. Penny, what about you? Anything you would be willing to talk through from your experiences?
Penny Evans-Plants: Yeah, first I wanted to say Beth, I thought that was beautiful, and I think that your early experiences really prepared you well for your later role in technology. And it's obvious that you have a very high emotional intelligence, which I think probably helps you be a much better leader. So I appreciate that. And I agree with Beth. I mean, obviously I've had a number of assumptions related to being a woman in technology leadership, and I have been the only woman in the room before. It's much more rare now for that to be the case, but that has happened. I can distinctly remember one time at a conference and we were looking for a particular product, and so a male colleague and I were going to the different vendors and asking for demos. And I was sitting on a stool and I had my bag in my lap, which covered my name badge.
Penny Evans-Plants: And so the person, the man giving the demo did not know what my role was at the institution. And so he directed the demo at my colleague and he asked him questions, he talked to him the whole time. I would ask a question and he would answer to my colleague. And that was really the most blatant really time that I had something like that happen. And when we left the booth, my colleague was like, "Oh my gosh, I am so sorry. That was terrible." And he would keep trying to redirect him to me, but he had really just... I guess he assumed that the male was the leader of the IT organization. So it has made me even more, I think, sensitive to that kind of bias and trying to make sure that I'm aware of that and paying attention and trying to alleviate that if I see it happening.
Penny Evans-Plants: And I don't know, I've gotten to this point in my career where I'm really trying not to spend too much of my energy trying to fit into what somebody else's idea of a really good technology leader looks like. I'm trying to be a better person, be prepared, know the issues, ask really good questions, and then build my credibility through my work.
Michael Cato: Really appreciate that from both of you. I have to smile. It makes me remember a colleague and friend who was a CIO for many years, five foot tall, Asian, and her joke was, "I'm incognito when I go into the exhibit hall because no matter what's on my badge, they're not looking to me being the CIO. So while everybody else has to avoid getting stopped, they never bother me." I was on a panel recently where I was asked about the journey to CIO, where did you learn the skills that you found really helpful to be CIO, was the initial prompt. I gave a couple of answers that apparently surprised the audience, one of them being that I learned to be a human-centered leader from the women CIOs I was able to interact with later in my career. That the first part of my career, I struggled because so many of the depictions of leadership I would read in leadership books that I would see highlighted, one didn't really resonate with me because that's not how I led.
Michael Cato: I don't lead by telling people what to do and making them fit into the right places. And it was only I started to encounter more senior leaders who were women who were much more human-centered that I was able to see, oh, it really is possible to lead in a way that really is natural to me. So on behalf of my younger self, thank you to you all that I know that that modeling is there. So if I can maybe turn on the other side of that, one of the challenges I've sometimes observed with human-centered leaders is people are surprised that you are capable of making difficult decisions because they believe that human-centered means you're going to be unsure, you're going to waffle, you'll make the decision and revert it later. But that has actually not been my experience that those two things have to go together.
Michael Cato: So Penny, if we could start with you, would you be willing to talk about an example of a difficult decision you've had to make as CIO and what that process or experience taught you?
Penny Evans-Plants: Yeah, so I think some of the hardest decisions really are about choosing between a good option and a bad option. It's between competing good things and what's the better at the good things. And we've got to constantly be looking at what are our resources, our capacity to take on this project, our ability to be successful with this project. And so I guess I've had to learn that saying yes to something is also deciding what we're not going to do. And that's really hard, is saying no to something. And especially when you know that it's important to a particular department or group at your organization, but that prioritization I think can be very difficult to do. And now that we have AI, oh my goodness, it's even harder because it's exciting and there's all these possibilities of things that we could be doing that could really help our institution, that could benefit our staff, that could...
Penny Evans-Plants: If you're really focusing on the student, that could really improve the student experience here at Barry, but we can't do them all. And so really starting, going back to what you were saying, Michael, really starting with the institutional problem that we're trying to solve or our priorities, then how do we make those decisions and thinking about our data, the people that we have, and what do we need to provide for our people to be successful?
Penny Evans-Plants: I don't know about you all, but we've been doing a lot of re-skilling and up-skilling of our staff, not just IT staff, but the employees of the institution to really try to prepare them for what's coming with AI or what's here with AI. I guess really being very disciplined about what you pursue versus what you don't pursue is a part of being a
Michael Cato: Leader
Penny Evans-Plants: And that those decisions can be hard and you do have regrets sometimes. Oh, I wish we had done this instead because hindsight's twenty twenty, right?
Michael Cato: Yeah, I really appreciate that, Penny. It's so interesting that the power of a clear no so that you can say yes to the things that you need to say yes to. Yeah, thank you. Beth, what about you?
Beth Clark: Yeah, no, I really appreciated this question because I feel that too often it's misunderstood that if you're human-centered, you are soft and squishy and you can't make hard decisions. I am soft and squishy and I'm hugger and I love good conversation and I also know that people really love clarity and clear is kind and sometimes being clear and providing clarity means making the toughest of calls. I'll give an example. When I was at HBS, we had to bring everybody back three days a week post-pandemic and that was difficult. Some people had moved out of state, some people were hired when they were out of state and we needed to bring everyone back and went through that process. But one of our senior leaders, even though they said initially that they would move then was resisting that move and it was causing friction with the managers across the organization because that was my direct report and it looked like I was making an exception for a person who was a senior leader in the organization and I knew the impact that was having.
Beth Clark: And so it was one of the toughest decisions to say, "We talked about this, I've given you some runway, but it's much better for the organization if we're clear about our direction and we're consistent about our direction. I don't have exceptions for people who report into me because that means if it's what I say but not what I do, people don't like that. It doesn't show a sense of integrity." And so the team at HBS very much knew that I was fine with making even third rail decisions while caring for the organization. But I think that's just an example of sometimes in order to care for an organization, in order to... Humans want clarity. They strive to get clarity and clear really is kind. And so when you're not clear as a leader, if you're not okay with making those hard decisions, when you know they're impacting people and impacting the organization, people lose trust and respect for you and your leadership.
Michael Cato: I really appreciate that, Beth. I'm going to be walking away with that phrase and using it more often than clear is kind. I really appreciate that. I'll turn to you, Cynthia.
Cynthia Golden: Well, I think that was a great example to talk about because the other thing that people perceive, if they perceive you're not being fair, then that kindness and clarity pieces, it's hard to put that together. And so the impact on the organization can be huge in those kinds of situations. So thank you for sharing that. Now I think we'd like to talk to both of you a little bit about advice that you would give. If somebody wants to become a CIO but doesn't yet see a clear path to that, are there suggestions that you have for them given that we've talked about your paths today? Penny, you want to start?
Penny Evans-Plants: Sure. Well, unfortunately, it's not likely you're going to be handed a CIO-shaped career path. So I think you always have to be looking for experiences or opportunities that are going to help you grow as a leader. So maybe you could learn budgeting, even if it's on a small scale. You could volunteer to work on projects. I think it can be helpful, particularly ones that are cross-functional. Learn the basics of things like data governance, change management, project management. But I think most of all, really learning the business of your institution. How does it work? What's your culture? So your goal ultimately is to be able to connect the right technology, the right people with what your institutional strategies or priorities are. So really developing yourself as a leader, as a person can really help you take advantage of those opportunities then when they come along later.
Cynthia Golden: So Penny, of those skills and experiences that you just talked about, is there anything you wish you'd developed earlier in the process?
Penny Evans-Plants: My goodness, yes. I really wish that I had understood the importance of change leadership earlier on. I thought early on that if I was just logical enough in my explanation of why we should do something that everyone else would see the logic in that and fall in and say, "Yeah, okay, we should do that." But that's not the case. We go back to that, whoever was talking about negotiation earlier, so negotiating your competing priorities and working with vendors, really serving as a translator between the really highly technical side to the end user and explaining that why to people so that they can get the buy-in early on and they become your champions for whatever change it is you're trying to implement across the institution.
Cynthia Golden: So those negotiation skills are something people might want to think about working on well before the CIO role.
Penny Evans-Plants: Yes, agreed. And so if any of you have ever had a disc assessment or something like that done, and I know one of my very strong things was mediator, and I was like, "Oh yeah, I guess I do that a lot in my job."
Cynthia Golden: Beth, what about you? What advice would you give to someone who wants to become a CIO?
Beth Clark: I think similar to what Penny was saying, I would be really curious about the institution you're working in, really understanding and trying to find experiences that expose you more broadly to the institution. The CIO role, I think it used to be more of a technical role. It has really become an institutional leadership role. And so understanding the various parts of the business and how they fit together and having that big picture view and looking for experiences that expose you to different parts of the business I think is a really helpful way to broaden your understanding of leadership. As Penny said, I don't think there's one direct path to becoming a CIO. Some of us end up in the role was nothing we thought ever about doing, but find ourselves loving the position because of what it offers in terms of the change impact that you can have on an organization and on an institution.
Beth Clark: I would say in many organizations, I want you to stay in your box, but try to break outside your box and build friends in different parts of the IT organization that you're working in and the institution you're working in and build those relationships and raise your hand and say yes. I think that is something that I have done since I was really, really young. I was like, "Yeah, I'll take that on." If somebody can't solve a problem and it's not in your day-to-day, it's not on your plate day-to-day, offer to help. If you think you can help solve a problem, raise your hand and help solve a problem and never, never, never be afraid of saying yes. There's nothing wrong with saying no, but try a little bit of yes.
Cynthia Golden: No, these are great pieces of advice, I think. For both of you, is there anything you hope changes for the next generation of women leaders in higher ed IT?
Beth Clark: Beth? Penny, did you want to go? Oh,
Cynthia Golden: Okay. Oh, it does matter.
Beth Clark: Yeah, no, I really hope institutions continue to see CIOs as leadership roles and partners at the table when making choices about where the institution is going. I think seeing the CIO role less as a technical role and somebody who has to solve all the technical problems and more as an institutional strategist who can help you get where you're trying to go via technology intervention. I think that it's evolved over time, but I still see a lot of job descriptions or position roles that are built around the technology and not around institutional leadership, strategy, vision, et cetera. I think you'd find more women in those roles if you're not, again, having the unconscious bias around what a technologist looks like as opposed to what a technology leader can look like in higher ed. So that is my hope. I've been looking at this for a long time.
Cynthia Golden: Well, thank you, Penny.
Beth Clark: It's stubborn to move that along.
Penny Evans-Plants: Yes. I think Beth summed it up really well, but she reminded me of something when she talked about the job description piece of it. And so really thinking about what I hope would change is that not only would we write better job descriptions and really emphasize the leadership aspect as Beth was saying, but that the studies have shown that if for women, they're reluctant to apply for a job unless they can check every box or 90% of the boxes. Whereas men are like, "Oh, heck yeah, let's just try it. We'll see what happens." And so really hoping that women will put yourselves out there a little bit more and try to go for a job that you may not think you're ready for, but you may surprise yourself.
Cynthia Golden: Well, thank you both for those very, very insightful pieces of advice. I think our listeners or viewers will appreciate them. Michael.
Michael Cato: Awesome. And if we look ahead to the future, could I ask you both for an example of something you're excited about, perhaps from your current work or as you think about or you're looking forward to? Beth, how about we start with you this time?
Beth Clark: Oh, I'm just looking forward to everything,
Michael Cato: Michael. That's the right answer being new.
Beth Clark: Yeah. Right now, there's so much work ahead of me at UC Irvine, and I'm really excited about just the change that I can help to affect at the institution. But we are at a really interesting inflection point in technological history, and so I'm looking forward to seeing how this plays out in an academic setting. It feels at some points existential for us, but I think we'll come out of it on a really interesting, and I like to look on the bright side. I think it will be a really positive influence for higher education. So I'm looking to enjoy the wave while we've got it.
Michael Cato: Wonderfully said. And it's a demonstration of your commitment that you didn't talk about winter in California for the first time is winter. Since I'm in Maine and I'm jealous.
Beth Clark: People hear enough. I'm so looking forward to February. It's not even funny.
Michael Cato: There you go. And what about you, Penny? Is something that you'd be willing to share that you're excited about with your current work or you're looking forward to?
Penny Evans-Plants: Yes. Well, I am, as I mentioned earlier, still really excited about the potential that AI brings to an institution like Barry. We've really been trying to approach AI very intentionally, really all around our mission and service to our students and our institutional priorities, and it takes a lot of discipline. And so going back to being comfortable saying no to things, and we have a very creative and innovative faculty and staff who would like to do lots of things and have every tool there is. I think right now at least being disciplined about what tools we offer at the institution is important and helps us really focus our efforts and our money on what is going to provide the most value for the institution.
Penny Evans-Plants: I mean, we all know we've got to have really good data governance and making as much as possible that honest assessment of the return on investment or ROV, maybe return on value, and that can be really hard right now. But it's not just AI for the sake of AI that makes me excited. It's really how do we use those capabilities to help the institution make better decisions, really improve that student support? Barry is in a really fortunate place. We've been growing our enrollment over the last few years, but we have not added staff, and so it has created a situation where a lot of our staff are really overwhelmed. And with our mission, we are really focused on providing our students with a highly personalized experience, and we want them to be able to talk to a person as much as possible, but we really need to free up the staff and the advisors.
Penny Evans-Plants: So if we can do some of that backend stuff with AI that can then free them up to do more of the personal things, then that's going to be a win-win for everyone.
Michael Cato: Really appreciate that, Penny. Cynthia, we'll turn to you.
Cynthia Golden: Yeah, we have just about reached the end of our time. I think this has been really, really great conversation. One of the questions Michael and I like to ask our guests sometimes is what do you do for fun and how do you relax? And that's a way to wrap up our discussion today. Beth, what about you?
Beth Clark: Oh yeah. Well, I'm a runner, and so I love running, hiking, biking, being outside
Cynthia Golden: Generally,
Beth Clark: And moving to California has just hit the spot for me because I have a lot of gear for winter running. Then I left back in Boston, and so it really does clear my head to get out in the morning, but anything
Cynthia Golden: Outside,
Beth Clark: You'll find me there. And
Cynthia Golden: In
Beth Clark: Quieter moments, I'll be reading or playing guitar or just hanging out with the people I love.
Cynthia Golden: Well, thank you for sharing that. And Penny, what about you? What do you do for fun?
Penny Evans-Plants: My first thought was relax. What's that? But no, seriously, I really enjoy traveling. My husband and I, our son is in Salt Lake. We're in Georgia, so we do go see him as often as we can. We do really enjoy the mountains. My family all likes to ski. I prefer the lodge myself, but I do enjoy going with them while they'll ski and being able to read things that are not about technology, which is a nice downtime for me.
Cynthia Golden: Well, thank you both.
Michael Cato: I'll say a generous thank you to our audience for joining us today for the Integrative CIO Podcast, and a big thank you to both of you, Beth and Penny, for sharing your experiences and thoughts with all of us. As always, we welcome input and ideas. Please send your thoughts to the [email protected] email address. Thank you all so very much for being with us today.
Penny Evans-Plants: Thank you.
Beth Clark: Thank you.
This episode features:
Beth Clark
Vice Provost for IT & Chief Information Officer
University of California, Irvine
Penny Evans-Plants
Chief Information Officer
Berry College
Michael Cato
Senior Vice President and Chief Information Officer
Bowdoin College
Cynthia Golden
Executive Strategic Consultant
Vantage Technology Consulting Group

